Changing your Windows Live ID is a pain!
Fancy a shot of Truth Serum? This will not be pretty so tread carefully my friends.
[Update] I’m happy to report that as of July 15 the issue has been taken care of … I am a relieved camper … and I wanted to say thanks to the team at Microsoft for all the help … they truly went above and beyond to correct this issue.]
—-
Start your gaming history over or suck it up and miss out on certain aspects of Xbox Live. That’s what it ultimately boils down to if you ever find yourself in the unfortunate position of not having access to your email address and having to change a Windows Live ID on your Xbox 360. You’ll be told to get a new one and lose whatever history you’ve built up within the gaming community and you’ll be forced to miss out on things that require an accessible WLID like getting blue flames from Bungie.
The way it’s supposed to work is that you simply enter the password on the account and change it. Simple right? But what happens when the system won’t recognize any password change that you make? Well then my friend let me introduce you to hell … nice to burn you.

Most people don’t understand that your email address isn’t just an email address when you use it on the Xbox 360. For every other service on the internet an email address is just an email address. However, with Microsoft and its system your email address has to be established as a Windows Live ID. Why is that necessary? Only the minds at Microsoft can tell you why you have to transform your regular email address into a Windows Live ID before it’ll work on their network. A wise basketball player named Sidney Deane once said, “Some muth****s always trying to ice skate uphill”. In other words, they’re making this harder than what it needs to be.
After your email address has done its own Optimus Prime transformation, it is now stuck for better or worse in Microsoft’s web. This means that as long as you’re a good little boy or girl and you never lose access to whatever Gmail, Yahoo, Hotmail or various other email address you’ve turned into a WLID, you’re okay. But let’s say for some reason you’ve used an email from a DSL company and that DSL company decides to get rid of that domain. Let’s just say that you had no choice in the matter and you need to update your WLID now because the email address literally doesn’t exist anymore. You, my friend, should just prepare to enter a ridiculous fight that may very well put a legal battle in the Supreme Court to shame.
I know the support links and various other recommendations from Xbox and Microsoft would lead you to believe the process is as simple as logging into your console and changing your email address. But it becomes so much more difficult if you ever have to verify that you own the account. I’ve personally given Xbox Support the birthday, credit card, secret question answer and my left lung to prove that I am the owner of an account that I’m trying to update the WLID on. Xbox Support has verified that information. That would be awesome except for the fact that Xbox Support can’t help me with a WLID problem and instead the WLID team has to ultimately fix my situation. So you’re saying that Xbox can’t help you with an Xbox problem? Yes, that’s exactly what I’m saying.
Sharing is Caring
Pages: 1 2

July 14th, 2011 at 10:33 am
Maybe this can be changed with the new LIVE cloud?
July 14th, 2011 at 10:35 am
not if that cloud uses WLID lol
July 14th, 2011 at 10:40 am
Man, this is a long ass article! LOL! But I did notice that my hotmail is linked to XBOX Live though. It sucks they have it set up that way.
December 26th, 2011 at 7:02 am
I’m also battling with this problem at the moment and the standard Xbox support advice of start a new gamertag isn’t an option.
DeaconBlade, could you shed a little light on how you finally got this resolved please?
January 21st, 2012 at 2:29 am
(EYEGotcha – it’s a long ass article cuz it needed to be, to say what had to be said. LOL)
Great article DeaconBlade!
I had the issue of it telling me my Gmail addy wasn’t available too when I attempted to change it. I just want to change it to one I use more often. I’m beginning to wonder if it’s worth the effort now! Geeeeeze what a nightmare you guys are having!!!
Just as a suggestion for those that haven’t lost their passwords YET (lol) and to prevent the nightmare from occuring if it hasn’t already, you might try using RoboForm. You can use the limited edition free, or can upgrade for a reasonable cost. It is a Godsend for remembering passwords and entering forms data quickly and effortlessly. I don’t know how people keep up with all their passwords without a tool like this…I sure couldn’t!!! You can check it out here: http://www.roboform.com/. You can also, as one option, purchase it through a partner TrialPay product.
Good luck,
Sheila Ü
February 6th, 2012 at 9:58 pm
DeaconBlade, could you tell me how you got this resolved please?
February 7th, 2012 at 7:05 am
i got your email Phil